Farmer’s battle over raw milk sales goes to Ontario’s highest court

TORONTO – A farmer and his supporters take their self-professed right to drink unpasteurized milk to Ontario’s top court today.

Raw milk farmer Michael Schmidt argues that by making the sale and distribution of unpasteurized milk illegal, Ontario is infringing on both his and his customers’ basic freedoms.

Schmidt’s lawyers say the charter includes “the right of individuals to make decisions pertaining to their own bodies and their own health.”

Schmidt has been locked in a decades-long battle with Ontario, and waged a hunger strike over raw milk, which he believes is not only safe but offers health benefits.

But the province doesn’t agree with Schmidt, calling raw milk a “significant public health risk.”

And Ontario’s lawyers argue the law is meant to protect public health and infringes neither Schmidt’s nor his customers’ charter rights.

Schmidt was originally charged in 1994 and later convicted of selling or distributing unpasteurized milk.

It’s not illegal for farmers to drink raw milk from their own cows, so a few years later Schmidt devised a so-called “cow share” program.

His approximately 150 customers bought ownership in a cow or herd for $300, $600 or $1,200, a system Schmidt believes is legal.

The Crown argues that Schmidt is still the one with legal title to the cows, as there is no evidence his customers “enjoy the benefit” of ownership except for a right to consume the milk and cheese products for a fee.

News from © The Canadian Press, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

The Canadian Press

The Canadian Press is Canada's trusted news source and leader in providing real-time, bilingual multimedia stories across print, broadcast and digital platforms.