BC doctor was ‘uncomfortable and unprepared’ to give trans teen a shot; HRT says he must pay

A BC doctor who refused to inject a transgender teenager with a prescribed hormone blocker has been found to have discriminated against the teen and was ordered to pay $28,100.

In a Sept. 1 BC Human Rights decision, family doctor Henry Ajaero argued he was “uncomfortable and unprepared” in having to give the shot, and made a quick decision on a busy day.

“This context is an explanation for Dr. Ajaero’s decision, but it does not justify his decision to deny medical services to a vulnerable trans youth because of her gender identity,” the Tribunal ruled. “(She) was entitled to receive medical services without discrimination based on her gender identity.” 

Dr. Ajaero also argued that, as a devout Christian, it was against his religion.

“However, it is not enough for Dr. Ajaero to say he is Christian and therefore justified in refusing to provide medical services to a patient based on their gender identity,” the Tribunal ruled. “He must establish, as a matter of fact, that there is a conflict between his religious beliefs and the medical services that (the) child… was seeking.”

The Tribunal ruled that the doctor had failed to do that.

The decision says Dr. Ajaero is originally from Nigeria and a devout Anglican. He opened a family practice in Delta in 2014 and has 2,800-2,900 patients, seeing 50 a day for 10 minutes each. He also receives between 200-300 reports about his patients every day.

In late 2020, the teen and her mother came to see Dr. Ajaero.

The child had come out as transgender early that year and was struggling with puberty. Her mental health was very poor. 

“I had begun puberty fairly early on, so I was already feeling a lot of the effects of testosterone and what testosterone was doing to my body … I can’t describe in words the amount of pain that caused me,” the child testified.

Dr. Ajaero referred her to the BC Gender Clinic, which prescribed a puberty blocker to pause her puberty and give her some time to decide her next steps.

The teen said it was “one of the best days of my life.”

However, the drug is taken as an injection every three to four weeks, and while it can be taken at home, the teen and her mom preferred to go to the doctor.

They showed up for an appointment with Dr. Ajaero, but after the doctor learned what the medication was for, he refused to administer it. He told the child’s mom he couldn’t do it for “religious and cultural reasons,” and there was no one else at the clinic who could.

The decision says the teen’s mom stormed out.

She complained to the College of Physicians and Surgeons of BC, which issued the doctor with a formal reprimand. 

At the Human Rights Tribunal, a four-day hearing took place, involving extensive testimony.

Along with arguing that giving the drug was against his religious beliefs, the doctor also argued that administering the drug was outside the scope of his practice and expertise.

He argued he was a family doctor and he also didn’t deliver babies, see patients in hospital, provide cosmetic procedures, do sports medicine, do minor surgical procedures, prescribe methadone, deliver medical assistance in dying, do abortions, and numerous other procedures.

However, the Tribunal rejected his argument, saying he was qualified to give injections.

“(The teen) was entitled to receive medical services without discrimination based on her gender identity. Given her age, mental health, and vulnerability as a trans person, this right was critical to ensuring her mental, psychological, and physical well-being. She went to see her trusted family doctor for help administering an important injection. I find that Dr. Ajaero did not consider (the) child’s needs at all when he denied her care,” the Tribunal said. “This falls short of conduct that can be justified under the (Human Rights) Code.”

The Tribunal said it accepted that Dr. Ajaero’s decision was made while working at a busy practice in the middle of a pandemic and while it wasn’t malicious or intended to hurt, it was still discriminatory.

Ultimately, the Tribunal ordered the doctor to pay $20,000 in compensation for injury to her dignity, feelings, and self-respect, plus $8,100 in costs.

News from © iNFOnews.ca, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Ben Bulmer

After a decade of globetrotting, U.K. native Ben Bulmer ended up settling in Canada in 2009. Calling Vancouver home he headed back to school and studied journalism at Langara College. From there he headed to Ottawa before winding up in a small anglophone village in Quebec, where he worked for three years at a feisty English language newspaper. Ben is always on the hunt for a good story, an interesting tale and to dig up what really matters to the community.