Elevate your local knowledge
Sign up for the iNFOnews newsletter today!

Before any seeds went into the ground, Cynthia Proudlove spent months meticulously planning her first commercial garden.
She worked out exactly what to plant at what time in the season, and secured a lease from the Regional District of the North Okanagan for a half-acre plot at the recently opened sncəcmałqtn Agricultural Park.
But now, after just one season, the regional district has refused to extend her lease, and given no explanation as to why.
“I did nothing wrong,” Proudlove told iNFOnews.ca. “I asked for assurances… and I got kicked out.”
The regional district’s decision not to extend her lease has left her thousands of dollars out of pocket after thousands of hours of labour were put into the garden.
“Being in a publicly-owned park with a legal contract, I expected security,” she said.
Instead, she got stonewalled.

The regional district’s handling of the situation flies in the face of the “supportive environment” pitched when it opened the park two years ago.
“Located in the BX area of the North Okanagan, sncəcmałqtn Agricultural Park offers a unique opportunity for farmers to cultivate their passion for sustainable agriculture… (and) provides prime agricultural land, community resources, and a supportive environment to help you thrive,” an informational sheet about the parks read.
After staying at home with her kids for years, the commercial garden was Proudlove’s entry back into the working world.
She was growing corn, squash, tomatoes, peppers, beets, green beans, cucumbers, melons and flowers for bouquets. What she didn’t sell through the season she planned to can for her family.
“It was more than just a job, it was more than just an income, I truly loved it,” she said.
But in June, almost all her crop was affected by pesticides sprayed by the farmer next door drifting onto her garden. Her veggies were left unsellable.

Proudlove accepts that Panoplia Farms owner Shawn Murray didn’t mean for the pesticides to drift onto her plot, and reiterates she’s not against pesticides.
The Ministry of Environment later issued Panoplia Farms a letter of non-compliance.
After the event, Proudlove followed up with the regional district, asking how it was going to address the current situation and the ongoing risk posed by future pesticide use.
A larger buffer between sprayed and non-sprayed areas was implemented, along with more signage and better communication about when spraying was going to take place.
But months after emails went back and forth, she received notice the lease wouldn’t be extended without any explanation.
And the regional district hasn’t been transparent about why it made that decision.
“The RDNO does not have a comment regarding this,” regional district spokesperson Stacey Raftus said in an email to iNFOnews.ca.

Regional district Area B director Bob Fleming, who is also the park’s site coordinator, didn’t return our call.
It’s hard not to see Proudlove’s cancelled lease as anything but retaliation.
“I think it’s completely unfair,” Dawn Guenette told iNFOnews.ca.
Guenette is one of the leads at the Three Sisters Garden at the sncəcmałqtn Agricultural Park.
“(I’m) shocked and deeply saddened that a model family could be treated this way,” Guenette said.
Guenette said it goes against the spirit of the community garden.
“We are there putting in literally thousands of hours collectively… we’re all in this together,” she said. “It makes me not very trusting of (the regional district’s) administrative power.”
In the months before Proudlove would find out her lease wasn’t going to be renewed, she filed multiple freedom of information requests.

Again, what she got back was far from transparent. Pages and pages of completely redacted emails.
Jordan Marr has been farming, largely organically, for the last 15 years and moved to the agricultural park last year.
Over the years, he’s seen lots of people try, and fail, to get into farming. A lot of new farmers tend to be idealists, but can’t cope with the reality.
But Proudlove was dedicated to farming, serious about it, and knew what she was in for, Marr said.
“I’ll be sorry to see her go,” Marr said. “Both sorry for her just on a personal level, but also because… getting these types of projects going has traditionally… been difficult.”
While it was pitched as a supportive and collaborative environment to promote local farming in the North Okanagan, it hasn’t worked out like that for Proudlove.
“I love all the groups that are in there… that’s what drew me to the park,” Proudlove said. “Now I know it was a false sense of security that I thought I’d be safer on government land, especially considering… (I did) nothing wrong.”
News from © iNFOnews.ca, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Want to share your thoughts, add context, or connect with others in your community?
You must be logged in to post a comment.
One response
I met Cynthia and her family at the beginning of last year as we were neighbors in the community garden. From the get go she and her family have been nothing short of helpful and generous with not only their produce but also with sharing her knowledge of gardening practices. This was obviously a family affair as they were consistently working together. One of our first encounters was over beans. She was musing over the fact a good part of a row of beans disappeared which she then commented- well good thing I planted lots. Notibly, the reason she planted lots was she fills her freezer for the winter to feed her family. And even still she would offer me some. She is a meticulous, experienced gardener. I was a bit sad to see them move over to the half acre as I enjoyed her presence next to me. Of course our garden visits continued and so did her generosity as she offered to grow us some watermelons for the three sisters’s expanded area,
which btw continued to feed visitors up until recently- “best I’ve ever had” was the comment I heard often.
Worth noting, the very productive tomatoes we grew over the arbor were given to us from her as she was done planting… these were her castoffs and yet they were one of the more productive plants in the sisters garden. We are most certainly a community that supports each other. What happens to one affects us all and as Cynthia has shown, she cares for this park and the wellbeing of this community. Her motivations go far beyond her half acre.