‘Hatred and self-pity’: Kelowna realtor loses appeal after defaming Airbnb business partner

iNhome

A Kelowna realtor who, according to a BC judge, made it her life’s work to destroy her former business partner, has failed in her attempt to overturn a ruling that found she’d defamed her one-time friend when their business went sour.

A panel of three Justices at the BC Appeal Court weren’t swayed by any of the points Jennifer Shannon Schwitzer made to quash an earlier ruling that she defamed her former business partner, Jillian Irene Little, for which she was ordered to pay $110,000 in damages.

Representing herself, Schwitzer made almost a dozen arguments, including that the original judge had miscalculated her award and that her comments weren’t defamation.

Schwitzer also wanted a sealing order put on the case, because the court documents contained personal and financial information about her and she was concerned Little would “make mischief’ with her personal information.

In declining the sealing order the Justice pointed out that such an order blocked it from the general public, not the other party and therefore was pointless.

The Appeal court decision comes almost a year after Schwitzer and Little battled it out in court during a trial that lasted more than three weeks and saw them berated by the judge for their behaviour.

Justice David Crerar didn’t mince his words when he said that both women showed “vengeful airings” of petty grievances, and that their dislike for each other erupted in overt displays of spite.

“That hatred, combined with their desperate self-interest, and their pervasive sense of moral outrage and self-pity, has obliterated any sense of objectivity and balance, and rendered it difficult to believe anything that either party said,” Justice Crerar said in the December 2025 decision.

Their relationship wasn’t always hostile when in 2020 they bought a $1-million property in Kelowna and a $900,000 property in Vernon to let as vacation rentals.

However, the business didn’t go as planned, and by the summer of 2022, the business wasn’t doing well, and the relationship had deteriorated before it “exploded.”

Moving forward, they negotiated with increased “acrimony, vitriol, and distrust,” the judge said.

Money was withdrawn, and locks changed. Schwitzer ended up being arrested by the RCMP after Little complained she had no right to be in one of the houses.

Schwitzer then sued Little over their contract, and in turn Little countersued for defamation.

“I can’t wait to write a book about the current evil I’m encountering with a previous business partner. Pure monster,” Schwitzer wrote on Facebook.

A friend of Schwitzer’s complained to Little bosses at CIBC about his mortgage, and she ended up losing her job. 

Representing themselves, they battled it out in court, and the Justice found the statement was defamatory. He awarded Little $60,000 plus $50,000 in punitive damages.

However, when all was said and done and the finances were worked out, it left Little to pay just $724 to her former business partner, with the Justice telling them to “move on with your lives.”

The Justice also had some strong words about their behaviour throughout, saying that taxpayers had had to subsidize their “vengeful airings” of “every petty grievance” as they ate up valuable court time.

News from © iNFOnews.ca, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Ben Bulmer

After a decade of globetrotting, U.K. native Ben Bulmer ended up settling in Canada in 2009. Calling Vancouver home he headed back to school and studied journalism at Langara College. From there he headed to Ottawa before winding up in a small anglophone village in Quebec, where he worked for three years at a feisty English language newspaper. Ben is always on the hunt for a good story, an interesting tale and to dig up what really matters to the community.