Taxes, not Trump, driving thousands of Americans to dump US passports

Sometimes it’s the politics, but it’s always the money that leads more Americans to renounce their citizenship each year.

Calgary-based lawyer Alexander Marino hosted a seminar in Kelowna last month for Americans exploring how to give up their citizenship and he said interest has been growing every year for more than a decade.

“I have clients who come in and say, ‘I don’t care if you save me 50 cents or five million dollars, I’m renouncing,’ but I would say that’s a minority,” Marino, head of US tax law at the firm Moodys Private Client, told iNFOnews.ca.

While the US administration under the second Donald Trump presidency is increasingly adversarial to Canada, among the many controversies at the White House over the past two years it’s the cost of holding both passports that draws in the most attention.

Roughly 70 people who showed up to the Kelowna event. Marino couldn’t say how many would follow through, but the total number giving up their passports is on track for a record-breaking year, mainly because they have “two hands in their cookie jar.”

He said they’ve helped more than 1,400 people give up their US citizenship and green cards all over the world because the US is one of two countries in the world that taxes citizenship.

“No matter where you go, you are always subject to tax by the (Internal Revenue Service),” he said.

In the Kelowna area, there are more than 2,200 US-born immigrants, making up seven per cent of the city’s immigrant population as of 2021, according to Statistics Canada.

That’s the fourth-most among home countries for immigrants in the region behind the United Kingdom, India and Germany. The US ranked third among immigrants to the Kelowna metro area from 2016 to 2021, accounting for 315 people.

The Kelowna metro area also has a greater share of American immigrants compared to the rest of the province’s total immigrant population, of which they account for four per cent, according to Statistics Canada.

If they’re a dual citizen living in Canada, but they own and sell a Canadian home, own a business here or simply earn a salary, it’s all potentially subjected to US taxes. Marino said it has become increasingly difficult to avoid and onerous under successive US governments, including both the Barack Obama and Donald Trump presidencies.

It’s particularly challenging for people who are doctors, lawyers or entrepreneurs, for example, at a time when Canadian health authorities are trying to attract health-care workers. In professions where payment is structured under a company rather than a typical salary, the US taxes corporations “very, very punitively,” Marino said.

“I roll my eyes at the phrase ‘taxation is theft.’ We need taxation for services to keep society going, but what is theft is double taxation,” he said.

While it’s not cheap to renounce, potentially with a cost of thousands of dollars, it can save much more for people who want to stay in Canada and avoid paying US taxes for the rest of their lives and through their estates.

How many have renounced their citizenship from Kelowna or Canada isn’t known, but nearly 5,000 have done so worldwide this year alone. That’s on track for an all-time record, but Marino added that wait times to follow through with US authorities can be up to a year.

News from © iNFOnews.ca, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Levi Landry

Levi is a recent graduate of the Communications, Culture, & Journalism program at Okanagan College and is now based in Kamloops. After living in the BC for over four years, he finds the blue collar and neighbourly environment in the Thompson reminds him of home in Saskatchewan. Levi, who has previously been published in Kelowna’s Daily Courier, is passionate about stories focussed on both social issues and peoples’ experiences in their local community. If you have a story or tips to share, you can reach Levi at 250 819 3723 or email LLandry@infonews.ca.