Judge rejects women’s sex allegations involving Prince Andrew, US lawyer in financier case

MIAMI – A federal judge rejected a bid by two women to join a high-profile sexual abuse lawsuit and ordered scandalous sex allegations against Britain’s Prince Andrew and a prominent U.S. lawyer removed from the court record.

U.S. District Judge Kenneth Marra’s ruling Tuesday came in a case involving wealthy financier Jeffrey Epstein. The two women, identified as Jane Does No. 3 and No. 4, claim to be among dozens of women Epstein sexually abused as teenagers at locations ranging from a Palm Beach mansion to a private Caribbean island to a sprawling New Mexico ranch.

The women wanted to join a lawsuit filed by other alleged victims. The lawsuit against the U.S. government seeks to reopen a non-prosecution agreement Epstein reached with federal prosecutors. Epstein pleaded guilty more than six years ago to state sex offences and served a 13-month jail sentence, but could have gotten a much longer prison term if the Justice Department had brought charges.

Federal prosecutors opposed allowing the two Jane Does to join the lawsuit, which was filed in 2008, and Marra agreed.

“Justice does not require amendment in this instance,” the judge wrote.

Marra also ordered sensational allegations against Prince Andrew and well-known lawyer Alan Dershowitz, a former Harvard Law School professor, stricken from the court record. Both denied any wrongdoing, with Dershowitz contending in his own court filings that Jane Doe No. 3 made up sex abuse stories involving him. Buckingham Palace stood by Prince Andrew, the second son of Queen Elizabeth II who is also known as the Duke of York.

Marra said the sex abuse details had no bearing on the lawsuit’s goal of reopening the Epstein non-prosecution agreement.

“The factual details regarding with whom and where the Jane Does engaged in sexual activities are immaterial and impertinent to this central claim,” the judge wrote. “These unnecessary details shall be stricken.”

Buckingham Palace had no comment Tuesday, referring to its past denials. Dershowitz, in a statement, called the decision “a vindication of my position” and said it should serve as a warning to attorneys against making unsupported allegations.

Miami attorney David O. Markus, a former Dershowitz student and close friend, said Marra made the right decision.

“Judge Marra saw through all the noise and correctly found that this is a court of law, not a tabloid which prints first and looks for evidence later. These absurd allegations have no place in our legal system,” Markus, who is not involved in the case, said in an email.

Brad Edwards, an attorney for the Jane Does, said the women could still participate in the case later and that the sex abuse allegations may surface again as evidence. Marra’s did not rule on whether the claims were true or false, or if they may be admissible in the future.

“We look forward to those later stages,” Edwards said.

The lawsuit, filed by two other Jane Doe victims, claims federal prosecutors improperly concealed the Epstein non-prosecution agreement, violating federal victims’ rights laws. If it is reopened, Epstein could be exposed anew to federal prosecution and the U.S. government could be forced to pay the women damages.

Epstein has already reached out-of-court financial settlements with dozens of the victims.

___

Follow Curt Anderson on Twitter: http://twitter.com/Miamicurt

News from © The Associated Press, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Share this story!

Join the Conversation!

Want to share your thoughts, add context, or connect with others in your community?

One response

  1. The American two tiered justice system is still in effect. Epstein got a 13 month sentence during which his cell door was never locked. There is a picture of Andrew with his arm around Jane Doe #3’s waist. At least Prince Andrew and Allen Dershowitz look like sh! t. So does District Judge Kenneth Marra.

The Associated Press

The Associated Press is an independent global news organization dedicated to factual reporting. Founded in 1846, AP today remains the most trusted source of fast, accurate, unbiased news in all formats and the essential provider of the technology and services vital to the news business. More than half the world’s population sees AP journalism every day.