New documents show Manitoba premier’s attache drafted apology for minister

WINNIPEG – Newly released documents show Manitoba’s aboriginal affairs minister rejected an initial draft apology for comments he made referring to ignorant white people.

Documents obtained by The Canadian Press shed new light on the government’s response to a controversy that erupted after Eric Robinson criticized a burlesque show fundraiser at the Osborne House women’s shelter in Winnipeg.

Robinson had told a staffer in his department that the fundraiser was inappropriate and revealed the — quote — “ignorance of do-good white people.”

On Aug. 23, Matthew Williamson, the premier’s press secretary, emailed Robinson with a draft apology that said “I regret the comment … and I apologize.”

The draft apology would also have had Robinson say that he has the “deepest respect” for the work done at the women’s shelter, and Williamson asked Robinson to call him to discuss the wording.

An hour later, Williamson sent a revised version that apologized only for the words Robinson chose, and it was that version that Robinson released.

The apology was dismissed by the head of the women’s shelter as half-hearted and insincere.

Robinson later told reporters no one had forced him to apologize and he had used his own words.

Robinson was not available for an interview Wednesday. Williamson said he had redrafted the initial apology after speaking with Robinson.

The documents were obtained by The Canadian Press under the province’s freedom of information law.

Manitoba Premier Greg Selinger rejected opposition demands to reprimand Robinson, who is also the province’s deputy premier.

Selinger said in August Robinson is staying in cabinet because he has done a good job.