JONESIE: What is really going on with Taxpayers First?

The Kelowna municipal election has truly taken a turn for the bizarre courtesy of the City’s first political slate.

If you haven’t been keeping track, nearly every day Taxpayers First has one-upped itself on pie-in-the-sky goodies that make American politics look sane and orderly.

Already they’ve made hundreds of millions of dollars in promises along with its stated raison d’etre: No tax increases for four years. They came out of the gate looking like a credible conservative crew. Then their five members packed themselves into their clown car and started handing out balloon animals and lollipops across the city.

First they proposed shutting down the regional district and building a massive building at the site of the KLO offices. Then they proposed buying the Kelowna portion of the $50 million CN rail line. They promised to spend $5 million in Rutland. Then they promised to give $5 million of Kelowna taxpayers money to upgrade the Southeast Kelowna Irrigation District, which the city doesn’t even own.

They claim they will pay for all these promises with what they call profitable public-private partnerships, which at worst aren’t legal and at best would commit Kelowna taxpayers to these projects into the next ice age.

But Monday took the cake.

In addition to promising a 2,500-seat theatre, they proposed building a moat, er, canals throughout downtown, again with the same expensive conceptual drawings.

Now think about that for a minute. The downtown’s underground infrastructure — sewer lines, water lines, electrical, cable and roads would all have to be dug up and re-routed or moved. Their drawings show the new Queensway bus loop under water.

It’s also likely impossible. Downtown Kelowna is built on fine glacial till. To build the Delta Grand hotel — above ground — required a year of compaction and vibro-compaction just to make the soils stable and force out the moisture. Now they think we can dig canals throughout downtown?

How again do they propose to pay for this without tax increases? By partnering with developers! Sell land! Long-term agreements! WIN WIN!

If only it was so simple. The massive Central Green site was already zoned for high density and it sat for four years and sold for $6 million.

The land they want to sell, which includes Memorial Arena, is protected by the Simpson Covenant that excludes commercial uses. Taxpayers First’s most recognizable candidate, Carol Gran, a former provincial government cabinet minister, was a councillor when the B.C. Supreme Court upheld the covenant.

She knows this.

In any election, council candidates make some strange promises. Usually they come from community-minded, good-hearted people who simply don’t have the experience to understand the difference. Reporters often give them a pat on the head and repeat the rhetoric because there’s no harm. But for some reason, Taxpayers First press conferences making these claims and promises were repeated by most of the city’s news outlets with nary a question.

This group appears to have plenty of cash behind them to make their push for a majority on council. At least two of their members — Gran and Graeme James, another former councillor — have the experience to know none of this is achievable. None of it.

Yet, they’ve clearly been planning this for quite some time with their videos and renderings and schedule of announcements. And there's still more to come. I can only imagine.

They know exactly what they are doing.

That’s what turns this from a laughable sideshow to something more dangerous. They are willing to promise the moon and stars to get elected.

Why?

— Marshall Jones is the editor of Infonews.ca

Join the Conversation!

Want to share your thoughts, add context, or connect with others in your community? Create a free account to comment on stories, ask questions, and join meaningful discussions on our new site.

4 responses

  1. Wayne Pierce

    Joe Kelownavoter This plan is so ridiculous you don’t even want your real name on it!I won’t even waste the time to expound on its stupidity!

  2. Good article Marshall… My thoughts exactly. Can hardly wait for the next episode. Stay tuned everyone!I keep thinking who’s going to pay for the Maintenence of all these dreams!!??Hence the name ” Tax Payers First”

  3. Marshall, I suppose this is just an opinion piece, but really? You investigate absolutely nothing, don’t go to the press conference so you can ask questions, but just spew your own conjectures?The CN Rail project is something most voters seem to want, and will likely be done one way or another. If you think tax and spend is the better approach for that, I you are entitled to your opinion. But you should make your case. The Regional District has lost 95% of its population over the years, but gotten no smaller? That makes sense?You come dangerously close to libel with your comment about their P4 idea not being legal. Do you have any basis in fact for that? And if you’d gotten out of bed to attend the press conference, you would have heard that their plan is to lease the land, not sell. Not sure if you’ve noticed either, but Memorial Arena is going to have to be replaced one way or the other. And the Community Theater is a relic that keeps getting more duct tape.Also, if you look on their drawing, Queensway is not under water. Do you just make this stuff up, or are you too lazy to pay attention? Let’s assume that the canals are too much of a stretch, do you think Kelowna can support a mid-level performing arts centre? Do you believe that the massive parking lots behind City Hall are the best possible use of one of the best locations in Canada?To turn the microscope back on you, why don’t you do any research, or even just show up to ask questions? You claim you want an informed electorate, but rather than doing research and providing real information, you try to be clever. And you are very patronizing to readers: “Reporters often give them a pat on the head and repeat the rhetoric because there’s no harm.” Your arrogance is showing. What is your agenda? It’s obviously not real journalism.

  4. Fred Steele

    Most interesting not even the rhinoceros party was that focused in its hay day.Good story by the way promises are one thing Disney could even imagine something this grand and Disney structures are in?You guessed it Disneyland.

Leave a Reply

Marshall Jones

News is best when it's local, relevant, timely and interesting. That's our focus every day.

We are on the ground in Penticton, Vernon, Kelowna and Kamloops to bring you the stories that matter most.

Marshall may call West Kelowna home, but after 16 years in local news and 14 in the Okanagan, he knows better than to tell readers in other communities what is "news' to them. He relies on resident reporters to reflect their own community priorities and needs. As the newsroom leader, his job is making those reporters better, ensuring accuracy, fairness and meeting the highest standards of journalism.