Elevate your local knowledge
Sign up for the iNFOnews newsletter today!
KITCHENER, Ont. – A convicted child-killer who wed another inmate and bore three children while serving a life sentence is once again seeking day parole, two years after having it revoked amid allegations she was mired in shady financial dealings.
Amina Chaudhary, 50, was found guilty of first-degree murder in the 1982 slaying of her ex-lover’s eight-year-old nephew, but has spent the decades since challenging her conviction and the resulting deportation order.
Officials branded Chaudhary a low risk to reoffend for years, citing her exemplary conduct behind bars and the discipline that helped her earn several degrees during her incarceration.
But a 2011 psychological assessment upgraded the risk to moderate, citing a “longstanding tendency to externalize blame” and “difficulties with accepting full responsibility” for her actions, according to documents by the Parole Board of Canada.
Those files suggest the board has grown increasingly suspicious of her activities, describing her as manipulative and “comfortable in being deceptive” to achieve her goals — traits it linked to “ingrained criminal values.”
The board praised her for completing several rehabilitation programs and undergoing counselling, but said it wasn’t convinced she had “internalized the material.”
“Despite positive elements in your file, including that you can behave as a model inmate and that you have shown a high degree of motivation in achieving success while incarcerated, the board has concluded that your risk to society on release would be undue by way of reoffending,” it wrote last year.
Documents show Chaudhary’s “soured” relationship with her husband Anees, a convicted murderer, raised red flags for some board members. They expressed their concerns in writing, adding the challenge of caring for the couple’s special needs children may have clouded Chaudhary’s judgment when previously on day parole.
The decision to pull her back into custody in 2010 stemmed in part from the board’s belief she was plotting to flee with her children while leaving the family home to her husband in exchange for her freedom, documents show.
In a recent twist, the case spawned a campaign for the preservation of evidence after photo exhibits that Chaudhary’s supporters believe might help prove her innocence seemed to vanish.
“The best recourse she had for vindication has pretty much been taken away,” said Alan Young, a lawyer and professor at York University’s Osgoode Hall Law School.
The school’s chapter of the Innocence Project took Chaudhary as its first case and has since referenced her situation in an application that would force law enforcement to keep exhibits in murder cases unless the inmate gives permission to destroy them.
Prosecutors maintained thirst for revenge led Chaudhary to slay eight-year-old Rajesh Gupta, who was left in her care while his uncle, her ex-lover, travelled to India for an arranged marriage to another woman.
Gupta was strangled in February 1982 with the drawstring cord of his ski jacket hood, packed in a cardboard box and dumped in a remote section of east Toronto.
At the time, Chaudhary — herself in an arranged marriage — was still recovering from an arm wound, Young said.
Parole board documents say she continued to have an affair despite the protestations of her family that “culminated in an assault involving your brother and a knife.”
Supporters raised doubts about Chaudhary’s ability to kill a struggling boy in her weakened state.
At her trial, however, now-disgraced pathologist Charles Smith testified that autopsy photos showed damage to Gupta’s skull indicating boy had been knocked out before he was murdered.
Attempts to find the photos and have them re-examined came to a dead end, stalling efforts to have Chaudhary’s case reopened.
Yet neither she nor her supporters have given up, Young said, noting the Innocence Project has heard from another witness and plans to file an affidavit in the coming months.
“The case is far from closed,” Young said. “It’s just one of those claims of wrongful conviction where we’re simply not getting all the pieces of the puzzle to come together.”
Chaudhary’s unwavering desire to overturn her conviction has long been a source of concern for the parole board, documents show.
She was nonetheless released to a halfway house in 2005 and later allowed to spend up to five nights at home with her husband, who ran a limousine business while on full parole and had obtained custody of their children.
In August 2009, the board noted that if not for an outstanding deportation order against her, officials with the Corrections Service of Canada would recommend Chaudhary for full parole.
A few months would bring a drastically different assessment. A parole officer flagged what the board called “discrepancies” in Chaudhary’s assets. The investigation that followed uncovered a number of business and real estate deals that officials considered “questionable” and led the board to label her behaviour “deceitful and likely illegal.”
Though no charges were laid, Chaudhary saw her day parole suspended and eventually revoked, while her husband was slapped with tighter restrictions and downgraded to day parole.
“We are appealing because there was no evidence of any real issue to revoke Mr. Chaudhary’s full parole,” said lawyer Joseph Neuberger, who represents Anees Chaudhary.
“On full parole he was a productive member of the community, running his own business with a family,” he said in an email.
Neuberger also denied reports the couple had recently become estranged after more than 20 years of marriage.
“They are only separated because she is still in jail,” he said. “There are no marital issues.”
The pair met in jail and married in 1989. Media reports indicate they had regular conjugal visits that led to the birth of their children.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Want to share your thoughts, add context, or connect with others in your community?
You must be logged in to post a comment.