Jury expected to consider fate of man who killed Toronto cop with snow plow

TORONTO – The fate of a man who killed a Toronto police officer with a snow plow is expected to be put in the hands of a jury today.

Richard Kachkar, 46, has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder in the death of 35-year-old Sgt. Ryan Russell.

The judge has told the jury there is “no doubt” Kachkar was driving the stolen plow when it hit and killed Russell on Jan. 12, 2011, so the key issue for jurors to decide is his mental state.

Kachkar’s lawyer has urged the jury to find him not criminally responsible by reason of mental disorder, arguing the troubled man was psychotic and had lost his grip on reality when he killed Russell.

The Crown has argued for a first-degree murder conviction, telling the jury that even though he was mentally ill, Kachkar knew what he was doing when he killed Russell.

Ontario Superior Court Judge Ian MacDonnell began his final instructions to the jury Friday and said he expects to wrap up around noon today, at which time the jury can begin deliberating.

The jury can find Kachkar not criminally responsible only when they are satisfied that his mental disorder rendered him incapable of knowing his actions were wrong, MacDonnell said Friday.

He said the jury’s first task is to consider a not criminally responsible verdict. If the jurors believe Kachkar couldn’t appreciate what he was doing, their deliberations end there.

If they don’t believe that, the jury must go on to consider murder or manslaughter, MacDonnell said. If they believe Kachkar meant to kill Russell, meant to cause him bodily harm likely to kill him or was committing a dangerous act that he knew could likely kill Russell, the jury must find Kachkar guilty of murder, MacDonnell said.

Kachkar would be guilty of first-degree murder if the jury believes he knew Russell was an on-duty police officer.

If the jury finds Kachkar is criminally responsible, he is at the very least guilty of manslaughter, MacDonnell said.

A first-degree murder conviction brings an automatic life sentence with no chance of parole for 25 years. There is no minimum sentence for manslaughter.

People who are found not criminally responsible are sent to mental health facilities for an indeterminate period of time and can be released only when a review board finds they are no longer a significant threat to public safety.

The trial heard from dozens of witnesses over six weeks, including three psychiatrists who testified that they believed Kachkar was psychotic at the time he killed Russell.

News from © The Canadian Press, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

The Canadian Press


The Canadian Press is Canada's trusted news source and leader in providing real-time, bilingual multimedia stories across print, broadcast and digital platforms.