Elevate your local knowledge
Sign up for the iNFOnews newsletter today!

A Kootenay skating club, which refused to renew a coach’s contract in retaliation after a coach launched a Human Rights case against them, has been ordered to pay $5,000 in compensation.
According to a Nov. 6 BC Human Rights Tribunal decision, the Cranbrook Skating Club refused to renew freelance figure skating coach Amber Flannigan’s contract 18 days after being served with her Human Rights case.
“The timing of this letter, so shortly after receiving notice of Ms. Flannigan’s complaint, supports an inference of retaliation,” the Human Rights Tribunal ruled in the decision.
The decision said Flannigan had coached at the club for five seasons but had a dispute over adult access to ice time.
The club rents the ice from the City of Cranbrook, which prioritizes youth access to ice time over adult access, and charges youth a lower rate.
Flannigan is a lifelong figure skater who, in her youth, had figure skated at a high level.
Now in her 40s, she coached at the club and wanted to skate during ice time reserved for high-level youth figure skaters.
However, because youth paid lower rates, in 2019 the Cranbrook Skating Club said it wasn’t possible for Flannigan to skate at that time, but offered little to no ice time for experienced adult skaters.
The issue clearly caused a rift between Flannigan, who was a freelance coach at the club, and board members.
Former club president Christine Malfair testified that Flannigan gave off an unfriendly demeanour and the situation caused “a lot of drama.”
After the ice time situation wasn’t resolved, Flannigan launched a Human Rights complaint, arguing the club was discriminating against her because of her age.
The case went to a three-day trial, and the decision went into a lengthy play-by-play of multiple incidents that took place over the years that followed. The club refused to pay her for choreographing the club’s annual Christmas ice show, instead classifying her as a volunteer. In another situation, she was told she couldn’t serve as a “coaches representative” on its board.
But while Flannigan argued age discrimination, the Tribunal didn’t buy it.
“Young people are an inherently vulnerable group, relative to adults. I find it reasonable to take notice that the City’s priorities reflect broader social interests in supporting the healthy development of young people, by promoting opportunities for physical activity and community engagement,” the Tribunal ruled, dismissing her age discrimination complaint.
Flannigan made numerous other arguments about the club’s conduct that were rejected by the Tribunal.
However, the Tribunal did find the Cranbrook Skating Club retaliated against her after she filed the complaint.
The club called the former coach’s case “frivolous,” stating it would harm the whole community.
In a letter stating her contract wasn’t being renewed, the Club specifically pointed out that the decision wasn’t related to her Human Rights complaint.
“However, in all the circumstances, its inclusion supports the opposite inference. The letter did not identify any reason for the Club’s decision and only mentioned the complaint. This suggests that the human rights complaint was front of mind when the Club was considering the issue,” the Tribunal ruled.
Flannigan argued for $50,000 compensation, but as most of her case was rejected, the Tribunal instead ordered the club to pay her $5,000 for retaliating against the Human Rights filing, and $918 as compensation for lost wages.
News from © iNFOnews.ca, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Want to share your thoughts, add context, or connect with others in your community?
You must be logged in to post a comment.