Elevate your local knowledge
Sign up for the iNFOnews newsletter today!

A Kelowna woman has won a legal fight with her strata after it refused her permission to have an emotional support cat.
According to a Sept. 8 BC Civil Resolution Tribunal decision, Strata KAS1677 gave numerous reasons why condo owner Debbie Eaton couldn’t have an emotional support cat despite medical evidence.
Eaton argued the strata’s refusal was a breach of the BC Human Rights Code.
Over the years, the issue of emotional support animals has been taken to the Tribunal on numerous occasions, with pet owners often, but not always, coming out on top.
The decision says the Saskatoon Road strata has a bylaw banning any pets except “one properly trained animal which is prescribed by a physician and approved by the Strata Council in writing to assist a resident or visitor with a disability.”
When Eaton bought her unit, she provided a letter from her clinical counsellor and her GP, which both stressed the need for her to have her emotional support cat.
However, the Strata refused her permission and began charging her $200 a week for breaching the bylaw.
The Strata made several arguments about why.
First, it said that it would create undue hardship because “some owners” have animal allergies, but gave no details. Then it said that Eaton’s cat was not trained or certified as an emotional support animal.
However, the Tribunal pointed out that no such training or certification exists for emotional support cats.
The Strata also argued that, as Eaton had her emotional support cat request denied before she bought her unit, she was bound by the strata’s pet prohibition bylaws.
“The law does not support this argument,” the Tribunal said. “(The BC Human Rights) Code… requires the strata to reasonably accommodate an owner’s disability up to the point of causing an undue hardship. So, I find Ms. Eaton did not agree to waive her rights under the (Human Rights) Code by going ahead with her strata lot purchase.”
The Tribunal ruled that it wasn’t an undue hardship for the strata to allow Eaton to have her emotional support cat, and refusing to permit the cat would have an adverse effect on her.
Ultimately, the Tribunal sided with the cat owner and ordered the strata to waive all the fines and allow the emotional support cat.
News from © iNFOnews.ca, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Want to share your thoughts, add context, or connect with others in your community?
You must be logged in to post a comment.