Elevate your local knowledge
Sign up for the iNFOnews newsletter today!

TORONTO — For decades, whenever Eugene Levy, Martin Short and Paul Shaffer got together, they’d revisit the earliest days of their careers, performing all the parts from the prologue of “Godspell” between the three of them.
The Toronto production of the musical in 1972 launched them (and a laundry list of other notables) into showbiz, and Levy says the trio reminisce “religiously” about the hippie musical retelling of the Gospel of Matthew.
But in his documentary “You Had to Be There,” which offers an oral history of the production and explores its impact, director Nick Davis lightened the workload for the trio.
Davis arranged a reunion of all of the surviving cast members — so for once, Levy said, he wasn’t on the hook to sing more than one character’s lines.
“It was fun to be around the piano again with everybody doing their own parts,” he said in a phone interview.

“I swear to God, we did an amazing job remembering everything for 50-plus years.”
That joyful reunion scene comes late in Davis’s doc, available on video-on-demand on Nov. 20 and airing CBC and CBC Gem on Dec. 27. For most of the film, the musical’s cast — which also included Victor Garber, Andrea Martin, Jayne Eastwood and Dave Thomas — reflect on the show independently of one another.
There’s next to no video footage of the production, which opened at Toronto’s Royal Alexandra Theatre on June 1, 1972, save for a short news clip of the cast rehearsing one of the numbers in costume.
There is some audio — illicitly recorded by Short on a tape recorder one night, the film explains — but to compensate for the lack of visuals, the participants’ recollections are illustrated by cartoons in the style of 1970s classics such as “Scooby-Doo, Where Are You” and “Schoolhouse Rock”.
The effect is entertaining, Levy said, if a bit weird for him: Imagine someone made a film about your first job, he quipped.

But that element also made it especially fun for him to watch.
“It was our first job and we were making some incredible friends who happened to be extremely talented,” Levy said. “And those friendships have lasted from 1972 till the present day.”
For many cast members, the production was a direct path to the Second City Toronto when it opened in 1973 — including Eastwood, who was the most established actor of the bunch at the time.
“Dave Thomas told me that I was the most famous person he had ever met in those days,” she said on a video call.
She’d starred in the classic Canadian film “Goin’ Down the Road” a couple years before “Godspell,” and had been in a few CBC dramas — “very dramatic dramas, no comedy at all,” she noted.
But she was keen to try her hand at comedy and the hippie musical was the perfect launch pad, she said.
“‘Godspell’ was a love fest. Everybody was comfortable,” she said. The cast was immediately tight-knit, like they’d been working together for decades, not days.
Though she’s no longer as close with her castmates as she once was, the camaraderie they built at the Royal Alex remains, she said.
As for the lyrics from 50 years ago, Eastwood said she practised in Toronto before going to the reunion in New York.
“I thought, ‘I’d better know my song,’ because Marty will make sure that everybody has to get up to sing a song,” she said. “That’s what he does, and of course Paul Shaffer knows every note for every song.”
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 17, 2026.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Want to share your thoughts, add context, or connect with others in your community?
You must be logged in to post a comment.