Too little known about underlying health of housing market: economist

OTTAWA – One of Canada’s foremost experts on the housing trends and household debt says what we don’t know about the market could hurt us.

CIBC deputy chief economist Benjamin Tal argues that despite all that is written about the market and measures enacted to either speed or slow it down, even policy-makers are operating somewhat in the dark.

The problem is Canada doesn’t collect or publicly disseminate some data that could give us a clearer picture about what is actually happening in the market — whether it is heading for a soft or hard landing — and whether households can withstand increases in mortgage rates.

For instance, he says, there is no information on the share of foreign investors in the hot condo market although anecdotal evidence suggests a skewing of Vancouver and Toronto prices, or the flow of rental activity, delinquency rates of non-conforming loans, or even the average down payment.

Knowing what’s happening doesn’t always help, he admits. The United States does collect much of this data and that didn’t prevent a crash in 2008.

Still, ignorance is not bliss either.

He says collecting better data would shed light on what will happen once interest rates start rising, a subject of much debate and fretting among policy-makers.

To head off such a hard landing, former finance minister Jim Flaherty moved four times to tighten mortgage lending rules, the last coming in 2012. As well, some analysts believe the Bank of Canada might have been moved to lower interest rates if not for fears it would light a torch under an already hot housing market.

Not that Tal disagrees with the decisions, but he says Canadians would have a better understanding of the market with better information.

He says with a newly minted finance minister, Joe Oliver, and relatively fresh Bank of Canada governor, Stephen Poloz, now may be the time to ensure agencies such as the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. and the financial institutions regulator, as well as private players such as the Canadian Bankers Association to either collect the data, or release data they hold.

Oliver’s office said the Superintendent of Financial Institutions has requested more information from banks and other lenders, adding the minister “closely monitor(s) Canada’s housing markets, and stands ready to implement further measures if necessary.”

The CMHC says it already provides information on its own portfolio holdings, and is always open to improve the content and reporting of the data.

News from © The Canadian Press, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

The Canadian Press

The Canadian Press is Canada's trusted news source and leader in providing real-time, bilingual multimedia stories across print, broadcast and digital platforms.