Elevate your local knowledge
Sign up for the iNFOnews newsletter today!

In a fiery rebuttal that clearly showed his frustration, a Vernon judge blasted a Crown prosecutor who put forward a sentence of house arrest for a Kelowna man caught with $100,000 of stolen copper.
“How, on any planet, can I give this man (house arrest),” BC Provincial Court Judge David Patterson asked Crown prosecutor Corinna Merry in Vernon court, June 4.
While the Crown prosecutor tried to justify the sentence, the judge quickly shot it down.
“Quite frankly, I think members of the public would say, given his (criminal) history, given the facts of this case, given the public outrage… there has to be some kind of punishment,” Judge Patterson said.
The case involved 45-year-old Kelowna resident Ryan Lawrence Robert Plotnikoff who in March 2025, was caught watching over a flatbed truck loaded with $100,000 in stolen copper reels.
The copper had been swiped from the Mica Dam in Revelstoke, along with the truck, and the main suspect in the case, Daniel Jay Anderson, had since died.
There was no evidence Plotnikoff had been involved in the theft, and his lawyer Glenn Verdurmen said he was asked to “babysit” the copper for around $500.
He was charged with possession of stolen property, and in a joint submission, lawyers asked for six months’ house arrest, followed by a six-month curfew.
In Canada, judges largely have to accept joint submissions unless the sentence would “bring the administration of justice into disrepute.” While judges do reject joint submissions, it’s rare.
The sentence put forward for Plotnikoff clearly didn’t sit well with Judge Patterson.
“He’s ingrained in the criminal lifestyle. Rehabilitation went out the window long ago. General deterrence went out the window long ago,” the Judge said.
In 2023, Plotnikoff made headlines after his lawyer convinced a judge he wasn’t trafficking, and that $4,000 of meth found in his car was for personal use. In 2010, while serving time at a Lower Mainland prison, he managed to escape while out working in the community.
Judge Patterson described his criminal history as “very bad.”
While the Crown pointed to Plotnikoff’s previous convictions for possession of stolen property, the judge read out his entire criminal record.
“Three convictions for theft of motor vehicles. One for a theft under ($5,000), eight possession of stolen property. One, public mischief. Four, failure to comply with release orders. One, obstruct peace officer. Two, failure to appear in court. Two, drug possessions. Two, possession for the purpose of trafficking. An impaired driving or prohibited driving. A possession of a motor vehicle without the owner’s permission. Use of a forged document. Four convictions for flight from police. Two convictions for fraud. One conviction for possession of a forged passport. One (break and enter) within intent. One, driving while disqualified. Two, driving while suspended. Unauthorized use of a credit card not once but twice. Escape from lawful custody once. Identity document… belonging to another person once. And possession of break-in tools,” the Judge said.
“This is the kind of decision that would bring the administration of justice into disrepute,” Judge Patterson said. “I’d rather give the man seven days real jail than one-year (house arrest).”
After a short break, the lawyers came back with a different sentencing submission.
Verdurmen said Plotnikoff had struggled with drug addictions most of his adult life, and that had led to his offending.
However, the 45-year-old had done some rehab and been sober since March 2025. The lawyer said he was doing well, had been working as a scaffolder for the last six months and making decent money.
“He tells me this is the best he’s been… he’s ready to continue on in doing what he sees as the way he should be,” Verdurmen said.
Ultimately, Judge Patterson accepted a joint submission for 14 days’ jail, which will be served at weekends, allowing Plotnikoff to continue working.
Plotnikoff also wasn’t ordered to pay back BC Hydro for the $100,000 of stolen copper, which, while recovered, was damaged.
While Judge Patterson said a restitution order was appropriate, the details given by BC Hydro’s insurance company were too vague. BC Hydro referenced the copper’s value being in a “confidential report,” and there wasn’t enough information for the judge to grant the order.
If the insurance company wants its cash, it will have to take Plotnikoff to civil court.
News from © iNFOnews.ca, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Want to share your thoughts, add context, or connect with others in your community?
You must be logged in to post a comment.