Top court OK with judge who copied one side’s submissions in ruling

OTTAWA – The Supreme Court of Canada has upheld a British Columbia judge who copied most of his ruling in a medical negligence case from the written submissions of the plaintiff.

In a unanimous decision, the justices overturned a B.C. Court of Appeal ruling that ordered a new trial in the case.

They also upheld the $4 million in damages awarded to a boy and his mother after he was born brain damaged in May 2001.

The appeal court ordered the new trial because the judge lifted 321 paragraphs of his 368-paragraph decision straight from the written submissions of the boy’s lawyers, mostly without attribution.

Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin, writing for the court, says that doesn’t warrant a new trial in the case.

She says much judicial writing borrows from other sources.

News from © The Canadian Press, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

The Canadian Press

The Canadian Press is Canada's trusted news source and leader in providing real-time, bilingual multimedia stories across print, broadcast and digital platforms.