Kamloops man to pay highest penalty ever awarded for sharing naked photos of ex online

A Kamloops man who shared naked photos of his former girlfriend in an online chat group has been ordered to pay her $50,000, making it the highest amount of compensation ever ordered for sharing an intimate image in BC.

According to an Aug. 18 BC Civil Resolution Tribunal decision, Aidan Kenneth Clare Hubbert admitted he shared at least 12 intimate images of his former girlfriend on an internet forum but denied he ever posted them publicly.

However, the Tribunal said that sharing the private photographs still met the definition of “distributing” and was unlawful.

“I find the widespread and repeated sharing of the (her) images favours a significant compensatory damages award,” the Tribunal ruled.

The decision said one photo was available for three to five days and received more than 30,000 views. The ex-girlfriend said that multiple people that she knows have recognized her in the images.

Hubbert said he never expected or wanted the images to be posted outside of his private messages with others on the forum and felt he had to build up trust with them.

However, the Tribunal ruled that the internet “does not forget.”

“The harm to the (ex-girlfriend) exists regardless of whether (Hubbert) expected or intended the images to be shared widely,” the Tribunal said.

The former partner, whose name is covered under a publication ban, said having her images shared has severely impacted her perception of trust in relationships.

“(She) says she has been living in fear and paranoia about strangers recognizing her, and about the images resurfacing and affecting her reputation in her personal life, work, and relationships,” the decision read. “She provided evidence that multiple strangers have contacted her about the images through her Instagram account, which is under her legal name.”

The Tribunal said this indicates that her full name is somehow linked to the images.

Hubbert said he was remorseful for sharing the images and at the time was struggling with his mental health and was addicted to pornography.

“He says that he was isolated, desperate for social connection, and ‘lost’ in his addiction and insecurity. He says he discovered an online community where users would share photographs of their girlfriends or wives, and he privately shared images… with users in that community. He says he did not think about the images being posted elsewhere,” the decision read. “(He) admits that he shared increasingly explicit images of (his ex) with other users over several months, and that the compliments he received about her appearance boosted his ego.”

The Tribunal said it accepted he was in a vulnerable psychological state at the time, but his conduct was repeated and deliberate.

“He knew or ought to have known that it was wrongful,” the Tribunal said.

The ex argued for $50,000 compensation, a far higher amount than the $5,000 limit, which was the previous cap under the BC Intimate Images Act. However, in March the limit of compensation was increased from $5,000 to $75,000.

Hubbert argued he shouldn’t have to pay $50,000 as it will keep him “stuck” and “unable to move past this situation.” He argued it will also affect his ability to continue therapy, which he needs to keep himself “on track.”

However, the Tribunal ruled an inability to pay is not a defence.

“She also has to live with the consequences of (Hubbert’s) actions for the rest of her life,” the Tribunal ruled.

Ultimately, the Tribunal ordered Hubbert to pay his ex-girlfriend $50,000, the highest amount awarded by the Tribunal in an intimate images case.

News from © iNFOnews.ca, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Ben Bulmer

After a decade of globetrotting, U.K. native Ben Bulmer ended up settling in Canada in 2009. Calling Vancouver home he headed back to school and studied journalism at Langara College. From there he headed to Ottawa before winding up in a small anglophone village in Quebec, where he worked for three years at a feisty English language newspaper. Ben is always on the hunt for a good story, an interesting tale and to dig up what really matters to the community.