Elevate your local knowledge
Sign up for the iNFOnews newsletter today!

James Miller was in Penticton for years after he sexually abused boys in Ontario, but the investigation into his historic sex crimes “ripped everything open” for one of his victims.
Now in his 40s, the victim’s statement to court in Sarnia Thursday described years of substance abuse, lasting mental health challenges and an inability to be intimate even with his wife, pinning the blame on the former Penticton city councillor.
“Every conversation with a detective, every recounting of what happened, every moment I had to sit in a room and be 11 years old again, I was there. I was fully there in my body in 1991, then I’d surface and try to remember what year it was,” he said in a statement to the court.
Crown prosecutor Suzanne LaSha read the statement aloud to the Sarnia courtroom before proposing Miller, 61, be sentenced to between four and six years behind bars.
Reflecting on how Miller groomed and sexually abused him, the victim said the memories would resurface “uninvited” throughout his life, but he thought it was managed. Then the investigation opened up old wounds.
“When I was on the stand I was locked and loaded. That part I could do. It was the rest of it — the statements, the waiting, all of it — where I kept disappearing… I went from being 46 and in full control of my life to being 11 and terrified,” he said.
Lawyers met again, Nov. 19, as a judge weighed Miller’s first of two criminal convictions this year. Two months ago, Justice Russell Raikes found the disgraced former newspaper editor and city councillor guilty of sexually abusing a young boy in the early 1990s while coaching a youth basketball team.
LaSha said the crimes “changed (the victim’s) life in every way” after he was groomed over time, then abused by Miller who was a basketball coach and “father figure” while the victim was in elementary school.
Through his court statement, the now-adult victim said he regrets not coming forward sooner.
“I apologize for not coming forward sooner. I stayed silent for years when I could have spoken, and I know what that silence cost. I have carried it forward ever since. Coming forward now does not erase what I did not do then, but I testified, I told the truth, I did not let the system down a second time,” he said in his statement.
LaSha said Miller took advantage of the boy after using his position as coach to find victims and, in this case, earned the trust of his parents. The boy even once gave Miller a Father’s Day card, which “underscores the success” Miller had in getting close to him.
Miller, who was previously acquitted of similar charges more than 20 years ago, took him for one-on-one trips, isolating and grooming him over time.
“It smacks of premediation and planning in a way that takes it outside of other cases that involve more spontaneous, limited targeting of a single targeted individual,” LaSha said in her submission.
Miller’s lawyer, Donald Elliott, initially proposed a sentence not only shorter than the Crown’s but one that wouldn’t be spent behind bars. He said similar cases have ended with conditional sentence orders, often through house arrest, of around two years, adding that a jail sentence should be closer to 18 months to two years.
“It might be a stretch, but I’m asking that you give some consideration to it,” he said, referring to conditional sentence orders.
Raikes challenged Elliott’s comments multiple times throughout the hearing, particularly when he suggested the victim’s “bodily integrity was not violated.”
“So, you’re at a Christmas party. You make unwanted advances on a woman… and force yourself one her and kiss her against her will. That’s not violating her physical integrity?” Raikes said, to which Elliott conceded.
They agreed when Raikes said it’s intrusive but not “as intrusive as other forms of sexual abuse,” though Elliott argued that would be more similar to assault.
Raikes challenged Elliott again when he suggested Miller had already faced punishment in the community after getting fired from the Penticton Herald, losing his position as city councillor and his trials were widely publicized.
“Are these sanctions or are they consequences?” the judge said.
The defence lawyer said it “depends on how you look at it.”
Lawyers agreed to return on Jan. 28, 2027, for Raikes to decide Miller’s sentence on his conviction for five criminal charges.
The Ontario Superior Court trial before Raikes was one of two this year and it centred on the accounts of two complainants. Miller was acquitted on two charges stemming from one of them, but he was found guilty on all five charges associated with the other, whose statement LaSha read to the court Thursday.
That included four counts of sexual interference and one for invitation to sexual touching.
A different judge heard the other trial and centred on another victim. On Oct. 2, Miller was convicted four charges, including two for sexual interference and two for invitation to sexual touching.
Lawyers will submit their proposed sentences for that case next month.
News from © iNFOnews.ca, . All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Want to share your thoughts, add context, or connect with others in your community?
You must be logged in to post a comment.